Cyber Crime and Cyber Justice
“Identity Theft Soars in 2009”
“Cyber Crime at Record Highs”
“Online Scammers Work Overtime in the Downturn”
These are the types of headlines that we see time and time again in the security news, reminders of the extent to which sophisticated online scammers are taking a toll on the safety and security of computer users around the world.
But, there is another side of the spectrum that many users may not be completely aware; law enforcement agencies around the world are working diligently to track the online scams and schemes plaguing the Internet, in order to find those responsible and bring them to justice.
Unfortunately, the Internet has made it easier for criminals to scam victims, as they work across borders, separated from those they are stealing from by countries or even continents. While investigators of cyber crimes do have additional challenges in tracking down criminals and bringing about positive change, progress is being made, both by regular law enforcement and by organizations – like the Computer Crime & Intellectual Property Section of the U.S. Department of Justice and the Department of Defense’s Cyber Crime Center – that work with other government agencies, the private sector, academic institutions and foreign governments to prevent, investigate and prosecute cyber crimes.
One of the most well-known law enforcement agencies in a full-fledged battle to track cyber criminals and bring them to justice is the U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI). According to its website, the FBI’s cyber mission is “first and foremost, to stop those behind the most serious computer intrusions and the spread of malicious code.”
The FBI has several cyber operations, including a Cyber Division at FBI headquarters, specially trained cyber squads at 56 field offices across the United States, Cyber Action Teams that travel the world to assist in computer intrusion cases, 93 Computer Crimes Task Forces around the country, and growing partnerships with other federal agencies.
The FBI also established the Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3), a joint effort with the National White Collar Crime Center, to serve as a clearinghouse to triage cyber complaints – then sending leads to federal or international law enforcement for further investigation. In any given month, the IC3 has an intake of roughly 20,000 complaints that are waded through to uncover patterns and go after the scammers.
“Bots. Worms. Viruses. Spyware. Hacking….Every day, criminals are invading countless homes and offices…not by breaking down windows and doors, but by breaking into laptops, personal computers, and wireless devices via hacks and bits of malicious code. The collective impact is staggering. Billions of dollars are lost every year repairing systems hit by such attacks. Some take down vital systems, disrupting and sometimes disabling the work of hospitals, banks, and 9-1-1 services…” according to the FBI’s website.
While investigators are experiencing an onslaught of cyber crime, justice does get served, and some of the “bad guys” of online crime are held responsible for their actions. One such accomplishment cited by the FBI was the guilty plea of John Schiefer, a California man who was prosecuted in 2008, in the first case of its kind in the nation, on federal charges related to his use of botnets. And, there have been other similar successes, shown in the compilation of news in the FBI’s Cyber Crime Headline Archives.
A major break came in late 2008, when the FBI, together with its global partners, wrapped up a two-year undercover cybercrime investigation of “Dark Market,” a message forum for online criminals where stolen information, as well as tools to facilitate online fraud, were bought and sold. The operation resulted in nearly 60 arrests worldwide, the prevention of $70 million in potential losses, and the FBI said, the confirmation that “while there might be honor among thieves, in the end, they are still just thieves.”
“It showed that we can get you no matter where you live. We were able to make internal relationships and work cases jointly with law enforcement in other countries. In the future there will be other joint cases in Europe and around the world. You don’t necessarily have to be in the U.S. for us to bring you to justice,” said FBI Special Agent J. Keith Mularski, whose undercover work was central to the sting operation, in an interview with CNET News.[1]
While there are undoubtedly positive steps being taken, cyber crime continues to be pervasive, as well as lucrative for online criminals. Working across borders to track the web of crime rings and finding global solutions to combat scams remains challenging for those trying to bring the perpetrators to justice.
“The bottom line is to make sure there are consequences for criminal cyber actions and similar consequences everywhere,” said Christopher Painter, Deputy Assistant Director of the FBI’s Cyber Division, at the International Conference on Cyber Security. The event was sponsored by the FBI in January 2009 to find global solutions to emerging threats, and brought in cyber experts and law enforcement officials from over 35 countries.[2]
“The bad guys need to know there is no free ride,” Painter said.
Contributed by Erin Earley at Lavasoft
[1] http://news.cnet.com/8301-1009_3-10234872-83.html
[2] http://www.fbi.gov/page2/jan09/fordham_011409.html